Islam: A Religion or a Political and Social Movement?

By Robert Lappin

As controversy swirls around President Trump’s move to bar individual’s entry to the United States from six countries with predominately Muslim populations, a much larger and more important issue is overlooked.

The issue is Islam, and the correctness of defining it as a religion, as it relates to our Constitution, and to immigration.

Islam is as different from Christianity, Judaism, and other major religions, as night is from day.

It has clear distinct political and social dimensions, which harbor views that are totally antithetical, inconsistent, threatening and violent to the non-Muslim world.

Islam, unlike other religions, is a political and social movement, whose religious arm encourages and justifies behavior of its adherents that is more often than not cruel, and unacceptable to those who are not among its followers.

There are Muslims — many Muslims — who do not wish to live by traditional, harsh Islamic legal precepts.

They have come here to partake in a modern, tolerant life.

Islam can and is being lived peaceably by millions, but as it is interpreted by massive numbers in the Muslim world, it is understood to teach its followers disrespect, hate and violence toward non-Muslims, and Muslims of different sects.

This fact is absolute.

This fact is incontestable.

Islam’s social dimension centers on patriarchal control.

Women living in countries ruled by Shariah Law are an underclass, subject to honor-killing, genital mutilation, and denial of basic human rights.

Gay, lesbian, bi-sexual, and transgender citizens of countries ruled by Shariah Law are reviled, abused, and treated as pariahs.

The penalty for homosexuality is death.

Readers of this piece are three mouse-clicks away from watching prominent, respected Islamic scholars debate whether the proper punishment meted out to gays is stoning or being thrown from a rooftop.

The Western World’s basic belief in the freedom of the individual is a concept incompatible with much of the Islamic world. Huge portions of the world’s Muslims think they should follow Islam’s sharia law.

Islam is a political and social movement cloaked in religion.

Its objective — at least interpreted by hundreds of millions of its adherents — is world domination, and thus presents a clear and present danger to the culture, traditions, and religions of the Western World.

One need only look at the plight of the nations of Western Europe today.

As a result of the European Union’s policy of open immigration, England, France, Holland, Belgium, Spain, Norway, Sweden, Portugal, and other countries have been inundated by millions of Muslims, most of whom are not — and quite possibly cannot be — integrated into the society of their host nations, resulting in the disintegration of the societal beliefs of their host nations, which are based on democracy, freedom of religion, and of the individual.

Misunderstanding and comparing Islam as a religion like all others, despite the fact that it is a political and social movement inimical to our way of life, has led to justifying the entry to our country of people many of whom have been taught to hate us and our beliefs.

This is a sad and dangerous perversion of logic, and a misguided application of tolerance. It makes a mockery of our openness as a nation and as a people.

Tolerance of the intolerant will lead to the destruction of our society and our way of life.


One Comment Add yours

  1. CharlieT says:

    Mr. Lappin, you say, “Islam can and is being lived peaceably by millions, but as it is interpreted by massive numbers in the Muslim world, it is understood to teach its followers disrespect, hate and violence toward non-Muslims, and Muslims of different sects.”
    Let me add one thing – while there are plenty, millions in-fact, of Muslims who want to live in peace, who have no heart for violence and blood, many sit idly by as other fellow Muslims engage in that behavior, and never stand up. Some do, but not many. In Judaism, there is the easily excitable left that checks the right at every turn. The Jewish right, has no issue condemning the left, but in Islam, you hear such few opposition voices because in actuality, even the ones who cannot bring themselves to shed blood, somewhere in the deeps of their minds, believe that it is the right course and are glad others are doing it for them.
    Islam at its very core condemns those who are not Islamic and even asks that the non believers be condemned. In the glory days when the Jews lived with the Muslims “peacefully’ Jews could not merely live, they were second class and had to pay a special jizyahh tax to remain in good standing. If you didnt convert, you needed to pay. Now, it is pay with your lives.

Leave a Reply